Here I will be posting my reviews of the many and varied pork pies I discover on my travels.
Please feel free to join in. I need to know where the best pork pies are.
» Second Opinion by Diziet on 15th Oct '07
6/10
vale of mowbray
a nice, soft pork pie. the crust wasn't crusty enough for my liking though.
» Second Opinion by Desert Creature on 11th Oct '07
9.5/10
Michael Kirk Pork Pie
http://www.porkiepies.com/
Multi-award winner
http://www.porkiepies.com/awards.htm
Me and Mr. Kirk's pies go back a long way. When I'm particularly glum I often make the long trip to Wolverhampton purely for a pork pie.
Appearance: Classic pork pie shape in the larger size - nice. They write custom messages in the pastry lid on request! I'm not totally convinced by the oval shape of the small pies. Meat is grey
Pastry: Crisp, but not dry, not only on the base but right up the sides as well. Slightly thinner than average on the sides which is probably the secret of that lovely crispness. Minimal pooling in the corners at the base.
Meat: Excellent quality, no gristly surprises, crumbly and seasoned to perfection. A small gap between meat and pie lid.
Jelly: Good, natural jelly. Not too much. Thoroughly permeates the meat for that melt in the mouth texture.
Aftertaste: A slowly fading pepperyness over about 5 minutes.
Emotional effect: Makes the world seem less pointless. Better than sex.
Conclusion: The best porkie pie I have ever come across. Enjoy a large one by yourself with salted tomatoes, fine red wine and Vaughn Williams on the hifi. Bliss.
Note that the pork and leek pie is every bit as good as the standard model. The pork and chilli pie is also very good.
» Second Opinion by Desert Creature on 11th Oct '07
5/10
Walter Smith Free Range Pork Pie
http://www.waltersmith.co.uk/
2007 Great Taste Awards Supreme Champion Free Range Pork Pie. As featured on the Chris Evans Drivetime show on BBC Radio 2.
I was very excited when I heard about this pie. There are Walter Smith branches dotted all over the midlands and this could mean I'd never be more than 10 minutes away from a quality product. I allowed myself to think positively for a change.
I've tried this pie from two different outlets and was very disappointed given all the hype. On each occasion the results were consistent.
Appearance: Unusual. Good glossy brown finish but the gloss turns out to be sticky jelly which should remain inside the pie in my opinion. Crust ragged but that adds to the hand-made charm. Sides ribbed my pleasure. Meat is grey.
Pastry: Generally quite soggy, comes across as being undercooked. Thickness is about right and even throughout with minimal pooling in the corners at the base. Slightly crisper on the top than on the base which, to my mind is, completely upside-down.
Meat: Not the usual ball of meat with the density of a collapsed star, which is a good thing. The texture is reasonably crumbly and the meat is obviously decent stuff but too peppery. Fills the whole pie.
Jelly: Good jelly. Not too much and penetrates into the meat nicely.
Aftertaste: Fine. No nasty surprises.
Emotional effect: Mood remains unchanged. Quality ingredients go a long way to ensure that I don't feel disgusted with myself afterwards.
Conclusion: Not offensively bad and streets ahead of your basic supermarket pie but don't believe the hype.