» by Xander on Sat 19th Sep '09 10:37AM
8/10
The book is a bit of a confusing read. Politically it is as bleak as it can possibly get. The real mystery is around the V character and what are his motivations. These are tentatively hinted as the story progresses.
One has not sympathy with the state in this graphic novel. They are as they say completely totalitarian, racist and utterly unsympathetic. Or are they? In many ways the bad guys in V for Vendetta are more corporeal than V. They have massive hang ups and are by and large prisoners of their own fascist system. As you would expect from an Alan Moore book his writing is fantastic at describing in short details the state of mind of every character. All of them are trapped with a crushed human spirit.
V is the very bizarre answer to all this. V is at his most sympathetic and heroic pointing out the stagnant human condition to the other characters and indeed the whole of England. V is a breath of fresh air to all this and the character is if anything an idea.
The book is not always concise as Moore admits some bits established earlier on don't ring true latter. David Lloyd's artwork is initially not inspiring but one being read really becomes part of the book.
England prevails!
One has not sympathy with the state in this graphic novel. They are as they say completely totalitarian, racist and utterly unsympathetic. Or are they? In many ways the bad guys in V for Vendetta are more corporeal than V. They have massive hang ups and are by and large prisoners of their own fascist system. As you would expect from an Alan Moore book his writing is fantastic at describing in short details the state of mind of every character. All of them are trapped with a crushed human spirit.
V is the very bizarre answer to all this. V is at his most sympathetic and heroic pointing out the stagnant human condition to the other characters and indeed the whole of England. V is a breath of fresh air to all this and the character is if anything an idea.
The book is not always concise as Moore admits some bits established earlier on don't ring true latter. David Lloyd's artwork is initially not inspiring but one being read really becomes part of the book.
England prevails!

